How to Start a Mentoring Program

How to Start a High-Impact Mentoring Program

Five Steps to Building a High-Impact Mentoring Program

Want to learn how to develop a mentoring program? That’s great. Mentoring is a proven approach to drive rich learning and development for both mentees and mentors. Mentoring also benefits the sponsoring organization. For employers, mentoring increases retention, promotion rates, and employee satisfaction. At universities, student mentoring is proven to improve student retention, boost job placement rates, and increase alumni engagement when tapping alumni as mentors.

Steps to Start a Mentoring Program

A thriving, impactful mentoring program is within your reach. But great mentoring programs don’t just happen. They are built through thoughtful planning and sustained commitment to guiding participants through the mentoring process while continually improving the program.

Deciding to implement a mentoring program is a great strategy for improving employee metrics like retention. A report from PeopleFluent shows that 78 percent of millennials said being a part of a mentorship program made them feel more engaged with their organization. In addition, BambooHR found 56% of new hires thought assigning “an employee buddy or mentor” was one of the most important things a new employee needed to get up to speed and begin contributing quickly.

As with any major project, proper planning is crucial to achieving your strategic goals. Mentoring programs can be highly impactful, but there are many factors that are critical to the success of your program. We’ve distilled our guidance into a video outlining the five key strategies for starting a high-impact mentoring program.


What is a Mentoring Program?

A formal mentoring program is a structured, often one-to-one relationship in a work, organization or academic setting. A well-functioning mentoring program requires strategic planning and organization to connect people, increase knowledge and build skills for future goals and milestones. Impactful mentoring programs train mentors and mentees to have productive conversations and meetings, providing them with career development tools and resources to accomplish set goals.

Implementing a successful mentoring program requires identifying the program’s purpose and vision, understanding your mentor and mentee pool candidates while incorporating periodic participant check-ins, and consistent communication and promotion to encourage the program’s longevity. When done right, a mentoring program in a professional setting is an enjoyable, rewarding experience for organizations and their people.

What are the Benefits of a Mentoring Program?

women collaborating at table

A well-planned, thoughtful mentoring program will encourage people to connect with others on a personal level and build strong, trusting relationships that motivate and guide toward future goals. Investing time in developing a well-organized mentoring program does not only support incoming professionals into the organization but also strengthen the skills of current professionals with, for example, management and collaborative goal-setting skills. A mentoring program can also help students acclimate to college life, as well as prepare to graduate and enter the workforce. A mentoring program can help members of a professional association further their development and network with others in their industry.

A mentoring program benefits the mentee and mentor relationship and helps the organization by building an inclusive mentoring culture centered on learning, sharing new ideas, and creating a shared vision. A mentorship program can diminish isolation and exclusivity, while increasing engagement, retention rates, and skill development. Read on to find out how you can create your own high-impact mentoring program in five steps.

1. Design Your Formal Mentorship Program

The starting point for any mentoring program begins with two important questions:

  1. Why are you starting this program?
  2. What does success look like for participants and the organization?

To answer these questions you will need to dive deep to understand your target audience. Make sure you understand who they are, where they are, their development needs, and their key motivations to participate. Translate your vision into SMART objectives: specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and time-bound. Objectives provide direction to program participants, establish program key performance indicators (KPIs), and help organizational leaders understand why they should offer their support.

Successful mentorship programs offer both structure and flexibility. Structure provides participants a mentoring workflow to follow and is critical to help participants achieve productive learning that reaches defined goals. Similarly, flexibility is essential to support varying individual mentoring needs across specific learning goals, preferences, and learning style.

Key design decisions include:

  • Enrollment – is it open, application, or invite only?
  • Mentoring style – can be traditional, flash, reverse
  • Connection type – possibly 1:1, group, or project
  • Connection duration – typically weeks or months, or perhaps even just a single session
  • Community/social aspects beyond formal mentoring, tracking and reporting needs.

A good idea is to create a program workflow diagram to explain each step of your program. You can provide details such as key actions, timeframes, support resources, and criteria for moving to the next phase. Mark areas that will require some flexibility to support user needs.

Mentoring software allows you to deliver a wide-variety of mentoring programs. Regardless if a small or large program, mentoring software is easy to configure and will save you time and cost in getting your program started and running smoothly.

See how software walks you through configuring a program

2. Attract Participants for Your Mentoring Program

The best designed mentoring programs won’t get far without effective program promotion, mentor recruitment, and training.

When formal mentorship programs are introduced in organizations, there is generally natural enthusiasm. Yet this enthusiasm doesn’t always translate into high participation rates. A common reason is the absence of effective promotion. Don’t assume potential mentors and mentees understand the benefits. For many, this will be their first opportunity to participate in mentoring. You will need to convince them that participating is worth their time and effort. Beyond participants, key leaders and stakeholders will need to be educated on the benefits of the program and strategic value to the organization.

Consider the needs of mentors. Building a solid base of mentors can be a challenge. It is important to understand the positive and negative factors that impact mentor participation. Once you have identified them, look for creative ways to reinforce positive drivers and lower the hurdles of negative ones throughout the mentoring process. For example, mentors are often busy people with limited time to spend. How can you help mentors be more efficient with the time they have to dedicate to mentoring? Also consider recognition and reward strategies. Formally recognizing mentor involvement can be very motivating and help attract additional mentors to the program.

Lastly, productive mentoring doesn’t just happen. Provide training to mentors and mentees regarding the program’s goals, participant roles, mentoring best practices, and your mentoring process. Help mentors and mentees clarify their own objectives. The need for training and guidance doesn’t end after the initial orientation. Provide tips and best practices throughout the mentoring program to help participants stay on track and get the most out of the program.

Checklist for Attracting Participants to Mentoring Programs

  • Promote the benefits to participants and stakeholders
  • Consider recognition and rewards for participation
  • Provide training and reinforcement throughout the program

Chronus mentoring software provides best practices, content and infrastructure to recruit, enroll and train program participants.

Get the eBook Now

How to Start a High-Impact Mentoring Program

3. Connect Mentors and Mentees

A productive mentoring relationship depends on a good match.

Matching is often one of the most challenging aspects of a program. Participants will bring various competencies, backgrounds, learning styles and needs. A great match for one person may be a bad match for another.

Matching starts by deciding which type of matching you’ll offer in your program: self-matching or admin-matching. Consider giving mentees a say in the matching process by allowing them to select a particular mentor or submit their top three choices. Self-matching is administrative light, which in larger programs can be a huge plus.

For more structured programs, such as large groups of new students at universities, or groups of new corporate employees, you may want to get the program started by bulk, or admin-matching. Evaluate various match combinations before finalizing as ensuring quality mentors for hard-to-match mentees can be challenging.

Mentoring Matching - 3 Steps for a Successful Mentorship Match

  • 3 Steps to Successful Mentor Matching
  • Create user profiles with rich data like gender, college, interests, and job function
  • Decide on your method: self-matching or admin-matching
  • Intelligently match based on profiles, improving match quality while saving time through software

Matching best practices start with a solid profile for all participants (mentors and mentees). Critical profile elements include development goals, specific topical interests, location, experiences, and matching preferences. Think about how you’ll want to match people, or if you’ll want them to save time by having them match themselves. For example, you may want to match female leaders with younger female employees, or experienced sales personnel with new recruits. For self-matching, perhaps participants might like to connect with someone from the same previous employer, or the same college. The more you know about your participants, the better chance your participants will have for a great fit and a happy, productive mentoring outcome.

Regardless if self- or admin-matching, see how the Chronus platform makes matching faster and easier with strong, intelligent matching capabilities.

Learn how our AI-powered matching works

4. Guide Mentoring Relationships

Now that your participants are enrolled, trained, and matched, the real action begins.

It is also where mentoring can get stuck. Left to themselves, manymentorships will take off and thrive. But some maynot. Why? Because mentoring is not typically part of one’s daily routine. Without direction and a plan, the mentoring relationship is vulnerable to losing focus and momentum. That is why providing some structure and guidance throughout the mentorship is vital to a successful mentoring program.

One best practice in successful mentorship programs is to ensure all mentorships have goals and action plans. This serves two purposes. First, it brings focus at the onset, which helps a mentorship get off to a good start. Second, it adds accountability to accomplish something.

Provide all mentoring relationships with timely and relevant “help resources” (topical content, mentoring best practices, etc.) throughout the mentorship. Chunk-sized content delivered at key points is ideal.

As a mentoring connection progresses, establish checkpoints where mentorships report on their progress. Even if your organization doesn’t choose to formally track the details, just the act of reporting progress helps mentors and mentees stay productive.

Lastly, have a formal process that brings closure to the mentoring experience. Within this process, provide an opportunity for both the mentor and mentee to reflect upon what was learned, discuss next steps for the mentee, and provide feedback on the benefits of the program and process.

Chronus software makes guiding or facilitating your program’s mentoring connections easy, enabling your participants to be highly productive.

Learn how guided mentoring can work for you

5. Measure Your Mentorship Program

Understanding how your program measures up to expectations may well be the most important phase of all.

Creating a mentoring program is a significant investment when you consider program management, infrastructure, and the valuable time of participants. Articulating the impact is essential to secure ongoing funding and support. In addition, the measure phase is also focused on assessing program health to identify trouble spots and opportunities.

Successful mentorship programs should be tracked, measured, and assessed at three altitudes: the program, the mentoring connection, and the individual. To be effective you need the ability to capture metrics and feedback throughout the program lifecycle.

Measure mentoring at three levels- individual learning, program health and mentoring connection activity

At the program level, build metrics around defined business objectives. For example, in a diversity mentoring program you may want to compare promotion rates of program participants to non-participants. Also track “funnel” conversion metrics, which show the progress participants make at each step of the mentoring program starting at enrollment. Conversion metrics provide essential insight into program health.

For mentoring connections, you want to understand mentorship behavior to identify roadblocks and opportunities. Common questions you will want to ask are: Is the mentoring timeframe too long, too short, or just right? Are mentorships getting off to fast starts or lagging? Are participants leveraging content resources you have provided?

For participants, you want to understand the impact of mentoring in terms of outcomes while acquiring program feedback. One of the easiest ways to capture outcome and feedback is through surveys. Ask participants and stakeholders how well the mentoring program met their goals and the goals of the organization. Also ask them for their ideas for improving the program.

View examples of mentoring program reporting

In Conclusion

Formal mentorship is an impactful strategy to develop, engage and retain your people. But running an impactful mentoring program goes way beyond just matching people up. For true impact on your organization, it takes effort, resources, and know-how. While it is no easy task to build a successful mentorship program from scratch, following the five step process will put you on the right path to achieve your organization’s learning goals.

Mentoring Software Can Help

Watch the video to see how the Chronus mentoring platform makes it easy to start, manage, and measure a modern mentoring program.

What Can You Achieve
with Chronus?

Software can drive 50% Increased Engagement. Learn how Chronus can impact your mentoring program.

Request Demo

Want to learn how software can drive success for your mentoring program?

Request Demo

icon-angle icon-bars icon-times