5 Reasons Why Workplace Mentorship Programs Fail

Workplace mentorship programs can be an effective tool for employee development, connectivity and overall organizational success. Mentorship—in which one employee acts as a trusted career advisor to another employee—has been proven to contribute to higher employee satisfaction, engagement, productivity and retention, among other benefits.


However, not all mentoring experiences are equal, and there are plenty of challenges that organizations face in creating a workplace mentorship program. Recognizing these common roadblocks and understanding the right solutions can help you build a mentorship program that will be a real asset to your organization.


This article explores some of the major reasons mentoring programs fail and offers tips on how to navigate these challenges.


1. Lack of Mentoring Program Purpose 

Without a clear purpose a mentorship program is destined to fail. In order for a mentorship program to be effective, everyone involved needs to understand the program’s objectives.


No Clear Mentorship Goals or Objectives

 Planning a mentorship program needs to start with the “why.” What does the organization want to get out of the program? This could include results such as increasing engagement or retention, improving succession planning, or supporting diversity and inclusion goals. These business objectives should align with the overall strategic goals of the organization. Without these clear guardrails, it can be a challenge for both administrators and participants to stay on track.


2. Flaws in Mentoring Program Design & Structure

 Planning is crucial for a successful mentorship program. Organizations need to think through every aspect of the program, from its overall purpose down to details of how it will be implemented and evaluated. Program managers should be clear on their roles and responsibilities, and participants should be given all the information and training they need to be fully prepared to make the most of their mentoring opportunities. Expectations should be properly set for how many meetings mentors and mentees should be having, as well as how to establish goals between mentoring partners early on in the relationship. 


Absence of Program Evaluation

 Along with defining your mentorship program objectives, it’s critical to decide how success will be measured. KPIs should be defined and measurement parameters built into the program plan from the beginning. Otherwise, it’s extremely difficult to evaluate progress and make necessary changes to improve the program over time. Mentoring software such as Chronus can integrate and automate the evaluation process and make it simple to see progress and areas of weakness.


3. Insufficient Mentor-Mentee Pairings

 Effective mentorship hinges on successful relationships, so it’s important to get mentor-mentee pairings right. Matching methods should be deliberately designed to offer opportunities for pairings with maximum potential. In designing your matching program, you should take into account compatibility factors such as goals, work styles, personalities and experience.


 Failure to Match Mentees with Compatible Mentors       

 A bad mentor match can actually be worse for a mentee than no mentor at all. Mismatches can single-handedly turn a potentially positive experience into a negative one, leading to disengagement and lost opportunities for both mentor and mentee. Putting importance on the wrong criteria could lead you to poor matches. Understanding the goals of the program and the wants and needs of your participants will help you better match people together. Using an AI-powered matching algorithm can provide you an easier and quicker way to match people across large numbers. 


 Mentor/Mentee Quality

 Successful mentorships take commitment and motivation on both sides. Mentors and mentees should both have a strong desire to take part, understand what is expected and be willing to make the effort. Without this baseline, it’s going to be hard to make a mentorship work. 

Just because someone is a tenured employee doesn’t mean they’ll make a great mentor, or that they’ll want to be a mentor at all. Equally, just because someone is younger or newer at an organization doesn’t mean they won’t have the skills and knowledge to share. Make sure you’re being intentional about the mentoring pool you’re creating in your company. 


 Lack of Diversity and Inclusivity in Pairing

 Organic or informal mentoring has often meant mentors tended to choose mentees who looked like them. Historically, this left employee populations such as women or people of color out of mentoring opportunities. A modern, formal mentoring program should ensure that inclusivity and diversity are built into the matching process so that people of different backgrounds are presented with the opportunity to learn from each other.


4. Low Program Engagement & Participation

Just because you build it does not mean participants will come. Even the best-intentioned mentoring programs can fail if no one participates. Watch out for the following triggers. 


Poorly Prepared Mentors and Mentees

 Failure to prepare participants for mentoring can have a huge impact on your mentorship program’s effectiveness — and not for the better. Even a little bit of training and preparation can make a big difference in success.

 While some mentors can be “naturals” at mentoring, everyone can benefit from training and support to help them thrive. Some skills that mentors can learn include:


  •     How to plan a mentoring session
  •     How to listen more effectively
  •     How to offer constructive feedback
  •     How to resolve conflicts


Ineffective Communication  

Clear and open communication is crucial for a positive mentoring experience. Mentors and mentees should agree on protocols for communications, including which channels they will use, frequency and type of communication, and expectations around response times. Don’t forget: people get busy. In order to keep mentors/mentees focused on the important task of mentoring, program admins should provide digital or real-time nudges, reminders and notifications to mentoring participants if they get off track or lag behind.  

You’re not going to get the full benefits of mentorship without committed, engaged participants. Program organizers need to be engaged themselves in making sure mentors and mentees are giving it their best. 


Lack of Incentive and Recognition for Participating

Mentorship offers plenty of intrinsic rewards, but explicit recognition can help participants stay engaged. Program administrators can help by recognizing program achievements, telling success stories, and making sure that both mentees and mentors know that they have the support of the organization.

 Mentorship doesn’t work well with halfhearted efforts. Participants should have a clear understanding of the goals of the program and what will be expected of them so that they don’t face unexpected roadblocks once they start. They should also be aware that there are resources available to help them if they are struggling for any reason. 

Mentoring software such as Chronus provides personalized guidance and next steps to keep mentorships moving forward.


5. Lack of Leadership Buy-In and Support

 A mentorship program without leadership support is unlikely to succeed. You should gain leadership buy-in before launching a mentorship program by clearly communicating the program’s benefits, showing how it aligns with organizational goals, and resolving any concerns. But once you have it doesn’t mean that buy-in will last forever. You’ll need to keep leadership engaged and aware of the program’s success and impact every step of the way. 


Toxic Organizational Culture  

Mentoring programs can contribute positively to company culture, fostering a more connected and engaged workforce. However, a toxic workforce in which cutthroat competition outweighs collaboration can sink a mentorship program before it even begins. Leaders need to be on board with the idea of mentorship as a way to bring the workforce together before any mentoring program can get off the ground. Getting leadership to talk about the program, or even better participate in it are great steps to ensuring buy-in and continued support for the program. 


 No Mentorship Storytelling 

 All the great work of mentoring won’t mean a thing if you’re not showcasing the success. This means a clear story about benefits and how they tie into the organization’s business needs, as well as compelling examples of success. Ways to showcase your mentoring narrative include:

  • Having successful mentor/mentee pairs share their experiences (think written word, audio or video)
  • Inviting participants to a virtual/in-person networking session to share tips and best practices
  •  Inviting mentoring ambassadors to talk about the program at company all-hands gatherings or team meetings


Mentoring Software Helps Workplace Mentorship Programs Succeed

 Simply creating a mentorship program is not enough—it takes careful thought, planning, oversight and follow-up to overcome common challenges and reap the full benefits. Programs that lack purpose and structure, effective participant matching and preparation, leadership support or strong engagement and participation are more likely to fail.

 Avoiding these pitfalls and creating a strong, effective mentorship program can be a complicated, time-consuming venture. Chronus mentoring software can help, with built-in services that include:


  • Customized mentoring formats and programs that meet your unique goals
  • Self-paced training for mentors and mentees
  • Program performance reporting on match rates, satisfaction, retention and more
  • Personalized strategic consultation on how to build/run an effective mentoring program


The automation and ease that Chronus offers allows you to focus on creating and nurturing a mentorship culture that meets the unique needs of your organization while maximizing potential positive benefits.


Find out how you can avoid common mistakes to build a successful mentorship program with Chronus mentoring software.

icon-angle icon-bars icon-times